SUBSCRIBE|ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION




CONTRIBUTOR
Burma's New Constitution: A Death Sentence for Ethnic Diversity
By ZIPPORAH SEIN Tuesday, October 13, 2009

COMMENTS (18)
RECOMMEND (47)
E-MAIL
PRINT

As Burma's rainy season draws to a close, ethnic Karen villagers in eastern Burma are bracing themselves for a new military onslaught. It is expected that this new military offensive will be much larger than the one in June, which forced around 6,000 people to flee for their lives.

We already have strong indications that the new offensive will take place in Dooplaya and Mutraw (Papun) districts, as attacks have been going on there throughout the rainy season.  Until three years ago, the Burmese government’s army mostly ceased operations during the rainy season, but now civilians get no respite.

So, why this new urgency to escalate attacks? The reason is the same as why the number of political prisoners has doubled in the past two years. It is the same reason why Aung San Suu Kyi was put on trial and her detention extended, and why the dictatorship has broken cease-fire agreements and demanded cease-fire groups place their soldiers under the control of the regime’s army. All opposition and ethnic groups must be crushed in the run up to elections in 2010. 

The elections bring in a new Constitution that legalizes dictatorship through a civilian front and a rubber-stamp Parliaments to do its bidding. For Burma's generals this Constitution is a way of securing their rule.

Despite having been lied to so many times before, the international community seems to be falling into their trap. Many countries have been making the mistake of focusing on the process of the elections, whether they can be free and fair, or at least create some political space.

How short their memories are, when only last year we saw the disgusting spectacle of a referendum on the Constitution while millions went without food and shelter following cyclone Nargis. No political space was created by the referendum.

Those trying to organize a No vote were harassed, arrested or beaten. The rigged referendum delivered an unbelievable result of "92 percent" in favor. Yet despite all evidence to the contrary, some still argue the 2010 elections could create a new political space.

While attention has been on the elections, little attention has been paid to the Constitution. Even those few countries which do focus on the Constitution have mostly focused on how it is undemocratic, granting 25 percent of the seats to the military and giving the military wide veto power over any change.

Attention has also rightly been drawn to other provisions in the Constitution, such as the head of state having to come from the military, 400,000 monks being denied the vote and the failure to repeal any of the existing repressive laws.

No one seems to pay much attention to what this Constitution will mean for ethnic people. The 2008 Constitution is a death sentence for ethnic diversity in Burma. Military appointed commanders will control ethnic areas. There is no level of autonomy. 

Our cultures and traditions are given no protection. We will be given no rights to practice our customs, or to speak and teach our languages. The process of Burmanization that has already been going on for decades will be accelerated.

The Karen know from personal experience just how bad this process is. Karen people in the Delta and Rangoon are being stripped of their identity and younger generations can't speak, read or write our own language, don't know our history, and even use Burman names to avoid discrimination in employment. Our vision is for a new federal constitution that will guarantee the rights of ethnic people.

The international community seems content to wait and see if elections in 2010 create a little political space. While they focus on the minutiae of politics in Rangoon and Naypyidaw, all around them Burma is descending into an even greater human rights and humanitarian crisis. They must wake up to the urgency of the current situation.

The crisis is unfolding before our eyes. Escalating military attacks on ethnic people are leading to a major humanitarian crisis and creating regional instability. Already we have seen thousands more refugees arrive in Thailand and China. More government soldiers have been sent to Karenni and Shan states, and with the generals breaking cease-fire agreements, the regime will soon also be on the warpath in Kachin and Mon states.

For those of us on the ground it is hard to understand why the United Nations seems content to allow the dictatorship to follow its own agenda in direct defiance of the Security Council and General Assembly.

Time and again the UN has said that there must be tri-partite dialogue between the National League for Democracy (NLD), ethnic representatives and the dictatorship.

The Karen National Union is ready to talk. Other ethnic organizations are ready to talk. The NLD is ready to talk. It is the generals who refuse to talk.



1  |  2 



COMMENTS (18)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

pLan B Wrote:
19/10/2009
Ko Moe Aung
Correct in your assessment again. Just a "gentle reminder" to those apologists for the west how far unbeknown to them the cause of this continuing chapter of B against B that they are cheering for is how the same method the Raj employed to expedite the process of colonization.
In this case Neo-colonization.

Ma Zipporah Sein

Until the deck is reshuffled you play with the cards you are dealt with. the best you can.
Walking away from the table is not an answer.
Unfortunately, the SPDC are the dealer due to their own ruthless tenacity and craftiness.
Who shall we blame for that result?
Do you think the SPDC is going to reshuffle on others' behalf with the past 20-pplus years of useless effort that they have thrived on?

Tom Tun Wrote:
17/10/2009
Zipporah,
The people in UN are more interested in what dress to wear than how to help the minority oppressed people around the world. They are the one who legally accept the people who rob the power from people.

Myo Chit,
However you try to destroy the culture of the minority ethnic groups, you will never win.

I personally think I would be stupid to think my culture should be the only culture. Languages are to communicate, clothing is cover the body and represent and express who you are. The way of life such as food and celebration are to enjoy life.

If you wipe out other cultures, do you think your way of life is fair? If you think it is fair, I ask you what is the meaning of social justice.

People anywhere around the world should be free to express who they are. I will always support the ethnic peoples and federation.

Moe Aung Wrote:
16/10/2009
Myo Chit,

You seem to emulate Indonesia like the generals. The DVB is hardly the shining beacon of national reconciliation. Assimilation is a natural process,whether one likes it or not.So is diversity;indeed it's inherent.

People do migrate internally,and more these days from a lot of economic pressure as well as war and repression.Intermarriage can never be stopped by any demagogue or autocrat in the name of racial purity. Burmese kings took thousands of captives from their wars and resettled them in the capital,encouraging them to marry into the host community thus enriching the gene pool. It was a form of Burmanization in situ.

If you were a minority, I bet you'd be singing a different tune. Integration and autonomy must be the way forward.


pLan B,

'Unless the original true culprit of this present unending cycle of violence admits its guilt'

That's never going to happen, and we've got to deal with today, not the past. It's 'SOS (same old stuff)', and now ancient history.

Greenland Wrote:
16/10/2009
Burmese history shows the Burmese/Burman can never/ will never respect the weak. Therefore, the KNU, being at the weakest state of its existence cannot expect the SPDC to give them the honour of a seat across the table and listen to their demands.

In stead of hoping against hope to see the face of SPDC, what the KNU should do now is as follows:-

- increase its strength, whether intellectual, military, or technical by harnessing the abundant resources of Karen population now spread across the globe
- change the attitude that the KNU members own the Karen revolution struggle. Instead they should bring in and involve every Karen
- the leadership should know when to serve and when to retire.

pLan B Wrote:
16/10/2009
The root of present animosity can be traced back to HRM court of Saint James.

After more than 60 years of often ruthless acts against each other, it will take one more generation of teaching true history to change the minds of future enemies that in reality should be brothers.

There was a time when the Karen almost occupied Rangoon were it not for the United efforts of other ethnicities.

The table has long turned. Now SPDC speak only through the barrels of their guns.

Unless the original true culprit of this present unending cycle of violence admits its guilt, the chances are this BUrman-Kareni animosity will ensue. Brother against brother is an all too familiar theme used by the neo-colonists to justify their treating Burma as a Banana Republic like.

Myo Chit Wrote:
16/10/2009
Moe Aung, LuSoeLay,

When the vast majority of non-Burmans are fully assimilated into the Burman culture thru mixed marriage or other non-violent means, there will be no ethnic division among the Burmese people. Elimination of that ethnic division/diversity will be good for our common future. I know diversity and division are not the same thing. However, in an illiberal society like Burma, elimination division is not possible without eliminating ethnic divesity. The junta has not succeeded because they have employed guns, instead of more sophisticated tools of Burmanization. With the right tools and time, we Burmans will get there. Accuse me of advocating Burmanization if you will - most of we Burmans back home as well as some in the west are in the same boat. Just look at DVB website, for example; they no longer have ethnic language pages. Apparently, they don't like diversity either.

Zam Mang Wrote:
16/10/2009
Than Shwe, please leave the innocent Karen people alone. You have killed too many Karens in the past. Why continue this massacre? They have been asking for freedom but you have given them death. Please make no more assaults on these lovely Karens who are our own brothers and sisters. They are the beloved children of the Union of Burma.

Moe Aung Wrote:
15/10/2009
Well said, LuuSoeLay.

Shame on you, Myo Chit. You don't have a hope in hell to 'eliminate diversity'. If the junta has had no success, no-one else will. Assimilation vs integration is a different debate, but it goes hand in hand with Burmanization that you'd be rightly accused of. Grow up.

Peace Wrote:
15/10/2009
Ms.Zipporah,

Please do not just wait and just rely on the international community. The international community seems content to wait and see if elections in 2010 create a little political space.

I know you all try hard to see Burma as a stable country.

Regarding to the below comment of "Kayin Lay" I agree that the current leadership of KNU have to create closer contact with its civilians. Support them to get involved in political issues and accept their opinions.

As I know, many educated young people are interested in the current politic issue. They want to be apart of it.

Please promote them to be apart of it and do not just encourage only your closest neigborhood to be apart of KNU's leadership, otherwise you would never touch the spirit of peace in your community.

Nowaday,thousands of Karen are spreading over the world. Promote their opinions and add it on to your leadership skills. The result of unity is peace. Learn more from your civilians and accept their opinion for the current issue.

LuuSoeLay Wrote:
15/10/2009
Diversity is the root cause? Whoever made such comment should live on the moon.

Be realistic: in today's world we live in there is more diversity than ever and dependence on each other. It doesn't mean that one must complain about diversity rather than solving it.

Burma is not the only country has 60 million plus people with a diversity. You probably heard "because of one bad fish, the whole bucket stinks."

We all know "IT" that is the actual root cause. Look at California State, it's about the same size, population and more diversity than Burma. What made it rank No.8 GDP in the world? I know California has some minor issues but my point here is that you cannot just blame on diversity.

Look at all developing countries, they have fair amount of diversity and complexity.

I hope you know which fish to remove from the bucket.

Kayin Lay Wrote:
14/10/2009
Muga Seepora...

Please don't forget that you are dealing with the most intelligent military junta.

The KNU must abandon the stance which it has held for 60 years. You KNU must use a different method and approach.

Sometimes, if you have to compromice you do so for the sake of Karen people as a whole and not for a few members of KNU.

Secondly, the KNU have to create closer contact with its civilians and not contact them when you need funding to organize meetings or workshop.

Now, what you have to think about is do or die.

If you do, get back to Karen Nation and ask them what they need. Some of them are fed-up with the so-called civial war.

Change your ideology and not keep doing what you dreamt about 60 years ago. At that time you were deeply inside burma. Then you went to the border. More than 10 years ago you could have negociated or talked to the junta. Now you have no where to go. Would it be better to think about compromizing for the sake of the whole Karen people?

tocharian Wrote:
14/10/2009
Perhaps it is time for the PLA to invade Burma to get rid of this evil regime. All of Burma could then be an "autonomous region" of China like Xinjiang or Tibet. We could then forget about these miniscule ethnic differences within Burma and pay homage to the Great Han Civilization and live peacefully under the protective Umbrella of the True Celestial Superpower of the world. Amen!

Greenland Wrote:
14/10/2009
Zipporah Sein hit the nail on the head on the current situation of Burma. The aims and motives of the ruling generals that are often left out or not commented upon by the mostly educated Burman nationalist news writers are now brought forth into view for all to see, understand and be aware of.

Burmanization has and will continue to its ultimate conclusion no matter what the country will look like, no matter the cost of human lives and suffering.

This is the true nature and true charactieristic of all successive Burmese governments since the country's independence. And it is supported and cheered on by not a few Burmese directly or indirectly, including many who claim or manifest themselves to be fighting/struggling for the country's democracy and federal rule among the opposition groups.

Ethnic people nowadays are no longer so naive as to not discern this fact of the Burman nationalism. How can one expect peace and stability to prevail in the country when such attitudes comes from the rulers?

Myo Chit Wrote:
14/10/2009
Diversity is the root cause that must be eliminated to get rid of Burma's problems. If all the Burmese were united as one ethnic group back in 1948, there would be no KNU, KIA, SSA, UWSA, etc. No rebels, no war, more money for health, education and development.

While some westernized Burmese activists promote federalism openly, I am glad that many domestic activists still believe that there would be less problems if there were no diversity.

My discussions with politically aware but inactive Burmese back home also reveal that they want to eliminate diversity by assimilating everybody into the Burman ethnic group, although they do not approve of the means employed by the SPDC to do so. So, most Burmese have the same aim as the SPDC with regards to diversity.

Even Yeni of "The Irrawady"(see Defeating the Wa would Win Wide Applause) supports attacking the UWSA and thereby weakening the ethnic armies. So - tough luck for ethnic identity - its days are numbered.

pecker Wrote:
14/10/2009
Zipporah, you exactly capture my moral outrage, distress and hopelessness I feel about the election next year and Burma's future(and I'm only a concerned westerner).

Unfortunately the international community feels it must show support for this election before it does anything else.

You comment about the impending violence. True enough, and if there is any 'unfinished business' after the election is over, the Tatmadaw will continue its invasion of ethnic areas but then with a copy of the 2008 constitution in each soldier's pocket, giving them 'legal' justification for further human rights abuses to mop-up any 'mess' left by non-cooperating ethnic and democratic groups.

Depressingly inevitable.

Yours respectfully,

Moe Aung Wrote:
14/10/2009
'The Karen National Union is ready to talk. Other ethnic organizations are ready to talk. The NLD is ready to talk. It is the generals who refuse to talk.'

The generals certainly are all action (repression, violence, manipulation) and no talk, whereas 'the United Nations is all talk, but no action.' It's time we took a leaf out of the generals' book. We must act for unity among all of us and together prepare for the next phase of the struggle.

Once we can act in concert and reach a critical mass both above and underground, notwithstanding the junta's divide-and-rule tactics, we shall overcome with or without outside help. A new Burma is worth putting aside our differences for the time being and fighting for.

To paraphrase Benjamin Franklin, 'we must indeed all hang together, or most assuredly, we shall all hang separately'.

Okkar Wrote:
14/10/2009
The KNU is finished.

timothy Wrote:
13/10/2009
Than Shwe accepts the Indian Army Chief and opinions creep up that the junta is countering China influence in Burma.

It is a dream to think positively in the situation under the abnormal junta. The way they think is far away from the reality and well-being of people. The junta will do whatever it needs to keep it in power.

The international community and the UN thinks that conditions will improve with 2010 election. They are dreaming and falling into the trap of Than Shwe.




More Articles in This Section

bullet Burmese-US Relations: ‘Mind the Gap!’

bullet ‘Radical’ or ‘Rational’ NLD Thinking

bullet A Debate Worth Having?

bullet Kudos to Abhisit for a Successful Asean Summit

bullet Defeating HIV/AIDS, Preserving the Future

bullet Confronting the Demons

bullet What Will China Do Next?

bullet Is It the Same Old Game?

bullet Untangling the Rhetoric

bullet Sri Lanka’s Road to Mandalay


 

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.