SUBSCRIBE|ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION


A woman in Leda camp (Photo: Alex Ellgee/The Irrawaddy)


SLIDE SHOW

The Vise Tightens on Rohingya in Bangladesh


By ALEX ELLGEE Saturday, November 7, 2009

COMMENTS (22)
RECOMMEND (60)
E-MAIL
PRINT

TEKNAF, Bangladesh — “I’ve lost everything in my life and now I can only pray that I don’t get sent back to Burma,” Haziqah, a 27-year-old female Rohingya refugee, told The Irrawaddy from her half-built mud hut in the unofficial Kutupalong refugee camp in Bangladesh.

Before coming to the camp, Haziqah lived in the Bandarban Hill Tract, about 150 km to the north, where many Rohingya refugees fleeing persecution in Burma have settled. She had just given birth at the time, and so was unable to work, but she and her husband managed to survive on the meager wages he earned from odd jobs in the area.

Slide Show (View)
However, their hopes of leading a quasi-normal existence were crushed when one morning soldiers from Bangladeshi border force, the BDR, stormed their village, rounded up all the Rohingyas living there, and marched them towards the border.

En route, she said, the soldiers beat her husband severely and pushed her along, ignoring the one-week-old baby in her arms. When they reached the top of a hill bordering Burma, the soldiers simply gave them a shove to send them back to the country from which they had fled.

In the chaos, she was separated from her husband; she later received reports that he had been captured by the Nasaka, the Burmese border force operating in Arakan State. She and some other women hired a boat to take them back to Bangladesh. When they arrived, Haziqah realized that her baby had died along the way.

Similar stories of brutality at the hands of the Bangladesh Rifles, as the paramilitary border force is known, are common among new arrivals at the makeshift camp. Like Haziqah, many of the women have been separated from their husbands and must struggle to find food and look after their children by themselves.

Since tensions broke out in August between Bangladesh and Burma’s ruling State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) over the latter’s construction of a border fence, arrests and forced repatriation of Rohingya refugees has dramatically increased.

In Cox’s Bazar, a district in southern Bangladesh where many Rohingya live in both unofficial camps and in camps supported by the UN’s refugee agency, UNHCR, different opinions are circulating as to why arrests have increased, but one NGO worker stated the most prominent one.

“The construction of the border fence means that the BDR will no longer be able to push back the Rohingya without the SPDC knowing; instead, they will have to pass through the gates,” he explained.

“The Bangladeshi government is afraid. In a way it’s a race against time to send back as many Rohingya refugees as they can, before construction is completed,” he added.

In order to escape arrest, many have fled to the unofficial camp, which unlike the UNHCR camp next door, receives no food rations. The Bangladeshi government refuses to accept Rohingya who arrived in the country after 1991 as refugees and instead labels them illegal migrants, leaving them to fend for themselves.

As a result of the influx of Rohingya refugees from the “push back” areas, the little food available to the refugees must be shared among more mouths, creating problems in the camps.

Unrecognized by the Bangladeshi government, NGOs are unable to provide food for the refugees, leaving them to find work in the nearby area. However, recent arrests at checkpoints, to and from the workplace, have led to many being too afraid to leave the camp to find work.

Zawpe, a Rohingya leader in Kutupalong camp, told The Irrawaddy that more than 500 people were arrested last month and another 100 so far this month.

“Because of the arrests, conditions in the camp are very bad. People are too afraid to go outside to find food. The food crisis is alarming,” he explained, standing at the top of a hill overlooking the maze of mud huts that make up the camp. 

“The government doesn’t let NGOs give us food and we are not allowed to work for food, so we are starving. It’s 1 pm and most the camp hasn’t eaten yet.



1  |  2 | 3 



COMMENTS (22)

Shwe Min Wrote:
16/11/2009
Ko Plan B,
Point well taken. Cheers.

plan B Wrote:
15/11/2009
Mr Junaid and Ko Shwe Min can start a similarly controversial debate with a never ending animosity that await them in the example of the Middle East.
The boundary of present Myanmar and Bangladesh is very well delineated.
After all is said and done, each side is responsible for the needed basic humanitarian effort.
Please let's not detract their individual responsibilities as well as those of the UN by winning empty historical points that serve neither the fate of Rohigyas nor Rakhines.
Clearly the result of the shrinking economic pie.

Shwe Min Wrote:
12/11/2009
Dear Mr. Junaid,

I have reviewed your citation and wish to comment.

No one is claiming “Mohamedens” (as used in citation) did not live in Rakhine. Kamen villages have existed in harmony for a few centuries.

A few centuries ago Rakhine empire extended till Chittagong (itself a Rakhine word), of present Bangladesh. Historical maps show that (or read “The Land of the Great Image,” Maurice Collis). This annexed area covered the present districts of Chittagong and Cox’s Bazar. The Mohamedens in these areas were not transplanted people – they were the locals! Reviewing your citation I see words that have no difference between Chittagonian dialect and Rohingya (tara- star, mata – head, hat – hand, to name a few).

So tell me how are people from Chittagong/Cox’s Bazar/Rohingya different; religious/racial/linguistic/cultural?

Interestingly, the small Hindu population in Rakhine feel perfectly fine identifying themselves as Bengali.

Aungsanthit Wrote:
11/11/2009
KKK,

The fence between China and Burma, that will be coming soon, but not from the Burma side.
It will be from the China side as long as this government stays in power. Believe me.
But as soon as there is a democratically elected Burmese government at home, that fence will be coming from our side also.

pLan B Wrote:
11/11/2009
Shwe Min,

"All I see is you and your intellectual 'Rohingya' friends taking advantage of the plight of the poor to advance your agendas."

You may be factually correct, but there are times humanitarian concerns should outweigh all other concerns. This is clearly one.

Dr Azmi's title might have made his post appear unreasonable, but his advocacy is clearly and purely humanitarian.

Getting the UN involved risks more anti-Rakhine propaganda. Let's cross that bride when we get to it.

plan B Wrote:
10/11/2009
China has no pretension in the pursuit of the commercial interest, unlike you-know-who. Remember, China is successful at that because of "Western negligence".
As it is now, you should be thanking China for the relative "laissez faire" attitude that is being espoused.

China will remain one of the most influential entities no matter who governs Myanmar. At least 25% of the population is still Chinese.

These two facts alone should sober anyone who thinks of China as something to trifle with.

Don't forget who has the fattest bank account, which is getting fatter everyday.

This is made possible by "commerce", even though it is a totalitarian state. Yet nobody mentions the similarity.


Junaid Wrote:
10/11/2009
Dear Shew Min,

Rohingya have never called themselves Ara Satigainya ("we are Chittagonians") nor Ara Bangali ("We are Bengali"). They only call themselves Rooingya > Rohingya.

"I shall now add three dialects, spoken in the Burma Empire, but evidently derived from the language of the Hindu nation. The first is that spoken by the Mohammedans, who have long settled in Arakan, and who call themselves Rooinga, or natives of Arakan."
(From "A Comparative Vocabulary of Some of the Languages Spoken in the Burma Empire," published in 1799, before Burma became a British colony.) You can read the book mentioned above at http://web.soas.ac.uk/burma/Comparative%20Vocabulary.PDF. Read this book and compare the vocabularies spoken by Rohingyas before the British colonial era with the language they use to communicate today.

KKK Wrote:
10/11/2009
plan B:

"I shall immediately stop wearing anything and refuse to buy any more "made in Bangladesh" apparel, starting with under garments."

You should include "made in China" as well.


KKK Wrote:
10/11/2009
Aungsanthit:

I am wondering why there is no fence between China and Burma. Don't you see thousands of Chinese have occupied your cities without a gun being fired?

I think you should have a Chinese name like "Lee Win Myo" or Lee Win Pyone" or Lee Win Pyaw".

plan B Wrote:
09/11/2009
If there is a perfect set up for a perfect scenario to vilify the SPDC this is it.
This tragic unfolding event could easily be construed by the west against the SPDC.
Kudos to THE IRRAWADDY and Mr ALEX ELLGEE for this exposé.

Shwe Min Wrote:
09/11/2009
"The Rohingya community has its own traditions, language and self identification. Nobody can compare them with Bangalis any more." By Mr. Azmi.

Mr. Azmi, you are on the verge of being ridiculous, if you are not already so.
There is no difference between Cox's Bazar Bengalis and the Rohingyas, especially amongst the poor.

Also don't group all Bengalis with the Rohingyas. Chittagonians and those from Cox's Bazar tend to identify themselves as "Ara Satigainya" (we are Chittagonians) first as opposed to Bengalis from other parts of greater Bengal. Of course Rohingyas Bengalis and those from say North Bengal-Rangpur have cultural traits that are different.

By the way, if you deal with Muslims in Sittwe (Nazi rwa, for example), the jury is out on whether they think of themselves as "Rohingyas."

All I see is you and your intellectual "Rohingya" friends taking advantage of the plight of the poor to advance your agendas.

Aungsanthit Wrote:
09/11/2009
Dear Kyi May Maung,

Pls go and find the big border fences between the India and Bangladesh and say again no fence should be there. Burma is as a union with many ethnic groups. Without those fences, there will be no more Arakan state.

plan B Wrote:
09/11/2009
I shall immediately stop wearing anything and refuse to buy any more "made in Bangladesh" apparel, starting with under garments.

This should force the Bangladeshi government to stop such atrocities against it own ethnics group.

Then again I would not like to make the situation worse.

I will just ask TBBC, ERI and 888 groups for advice.

Meanwhile the Rohingyas fate continues towards a holocaust-like scenario.

plan B Wrote:
09/11/2009
A sticky of an article by Mr Ellgee.
Where is a statement from UN?
Where is the IRC?
Where is the US 7th fleet?
WHy does Saudi Arabia not make some comment?
The double standards are glaring.

ARAKAN Wrote:
08/11/2009
Now is the time to struggle to get back the whole of ARAKAN from the crocodile (Burma) and the snake (Bangladesh). At this moment,the inhabitants of Arakan should realize how both countries have divided you and annexed your land.

You ARAKAN people should never forget that once you were an independent state (Kingdom), from Comila (present-day Bangladesh) to the Arkan-yoma (present-day Burma).

Mr.Azmi Wrote:
08/11/2009
Thanks to "The Irrawaddy" for focusing on the real situation of the Rohingya community, which is facing unexpected problems on both sides of the border.

We are very aware that unjust and barbaric racist actions will never bring peace to the region.

The Rohingya community has its own traditions, language and self identification. Nobody can compare them with Bangalis any more.

I request the world community, the UN, the EU and NGOs' and all other Human rights organizations to please help them by providing protection of all of their basic human rights in the future.

All humang beings have the same right to live on this earth.
Thank you.
Sincerely yours,
Mr.Azmi
Secretary General of Burmese Rohingya Organization in Germany (BROG)
Frankfurt-Germany


SNA Wrote:
08/11/2009
I agree, “No border should have walls”

There are so many refugee crises around the world but especially these Rohingya, who are suffering and starving more than any other refugees.

I knew about their situation but didn’t realize that the Rohingya refugees are suffering to that extent. I appreciate the writer for showing people these things are happening.

I hope the Irrawaddy‘s writers can continue to inform us about these issues and I hope the Rohingya will get better lives soon.
Good job.

SNA

Oo Maung Gyi Wrote:
08/11/2009
I am not Rohingya, I am purely Arakanese, my blood is surely red not black.
Rohingyas are not from Bangladesh, there was no Bnagladesh during the time of British India and the Pakistan era. It was East Pakistan during the time of Pakistan.
Why the Burmese military government is pushing them back to another country is a political game. The junta does not want Arakanese Buddhists and Arakanese Muslims to join together which will make strengthen to fight against the Burman race. The Arakanese Buddhist peoples do not understand due to lack of political knowledge and never study political science.

This is really the fact. Go back to the history of Arakan, Muslims are the king- maker in Arakan. Its clearly shown in the history of Arakan. Why today Arakanese Buddhists are against the Muslims, due to the divide and rule policy of Burman chauvinism.
Therefore all Arakan native peoples have to be careful in this Burman chauvinist period.





A Chakma Wrote:
08/11/2009
Bangladesh must be condemned for ill treatment of its own people - the Bengalis. Erstwhile Pakistan & Bangladesh governments had used these Bengalis as cannon fodder to colonize Arakan State. Now Bangladesh is refusing to take back its own people when that venture turned sour.

Kyi May Kaung Wrote:
07/11/2009
This is an exceptionally well written report about a terrible situation and the photographs also raise the bar for Irrawaddy and other reporting.

I hope the new US engagement policy regarding Burma takes border situations like this into account.

No borders should have walls.

Kyi May Kaung (Ph.D.)

The Diplomat Wrote:
07/11/2009
I am extremely pleased to see The Irrawaddy focusing on such a pressing issue and doing a great job of it.

The situation the refugees now face in the unregistered camps is extremely worrying.

Whereas the food crisis has gone up and down in recent years, and so have the arrests, it appears that this time the effects will be more catastrophic than before.

Its a very critical time for the refugees who need the International Community to step up and find a solution to the problem.

Any government would sympathise with Bangladesh's concerns but it's unacceptable for humans to live in such dire conditions.


Panda Gavin Wrote:
07/11/2009
Ellgee is the best!





Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

More Articles in This Section


bullet Children’s Rights Celebrated in Naypyidaw

bullet US Calls for Dialogue between Suu Kyi and Junta

bullet UN Passes Resolutions on Burma Human Rights

bullet Myint Swe: The Tatmadaw’s Next Top Dog?

bullet Handcuffed Statue Has the Experts Talking

bullet ‘Burma VJ’ Short-listed for Oscar

bullet Assessing the US-Asean Summit

bullet Coco Islands to Open for Tourism

bullet Global Fund Returns to Burma with Large Grant

bullet Mystery of the Handcuffed Statues


 

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.